1997
Emily Austin - Att. UCAA - 2nd Team All-Star

1999
Laura Peck - Def. UCAA - 2nd Team All-Star

2000
Erin Crowe - Att. UCAA - Honorable Mention
Jessie Judge - Mid. UCAA - Honorable Mention
Alexis Versfeld - Mid. UCAA - Honorable Mention

2002
Allison Morlock - Goal UCAA - 2nd Team All-Star

2003
Allison Morlock - Goal ECAC Upstate NY - 1st Team All-Star
UCAA - 1st Team All-Star
Mary Rice - Att. All-New York State - 3rd Team All-Star

2005
Jennifer Berman - Att. IWLCA Academic National Honor Roll
Lynda Buechel - Def. IWLCA Academic National Honor Roll

2006
Alicia Chace - Mid. Liberty League - Honorable Mention
Lindsey Grigg - Att. Liberty League - Honorable Mention

2007
Alicia Chace - Mid. Liberty League - Honorable Mention
Emily Bojarski - Mid. Liberty League - Honorable Mention

2008
Alicia Chace - Mid. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star
Emily Bojarski - Att. Liberty League - Honorable Mention
Kimberly Loucks - Mid. Liberty League - Honorable Mention

2009
Kimberly Loucks - Mid. Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Emily Bojarski - Att. Liberty League - Honorable Mention
Hannah Walters - Goal Liberty League - Honorable Mention

2010
Kimberly Loucks - Mid. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star

2011
Saryn Campbell - Mid. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star
Alyssa Cristaldi - Att. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star

2012
Saryn Campbell - Mid. Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Alyssa Cristaldi - Att. Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Hannah Walters - Goal Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star

2013
Christine Wright - Mid. Liberty League Rookie of the Year
Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star
Alyssa Cristaldi - Att. Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Katie VanDeValk - Mid. Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Jeannette Pendergast - Def. Liberty League - Honorable Mention All-Star

2014
Christine Wright - Mid. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star
Paige Fayette - Att. Liberty League - Honorable Mention All-Star

2015
Christine Wright - Mid. IWLCA Empire Region - 2nd Team All-Star
Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Paige Fayette - Att. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star

2016
Christine Wright - Mid. IWLCA Empire Region - 1st Team All-Star
Liberty League Co-Player of the Year
Liberty League - 1st Team All-Star
Ashley Flick - Att. Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star
Samantha Gladd - GK Liberty League - 2nd Team All-Star
Taylor Collins - Mid. Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
Hanna Gleason - Def. Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

2017
Jaid Baytos - Attack/Midfield - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Taylor Collins - Midfield - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Abby Collins - Midfield - Liberty League Honorable Mention Team All-Star
Kate Dillon - Attack - Liberty League Honorable Mention Team All-Star
Stephanie Scaia - Defense/Midfield - Liberty League Honorable Mention Team All-Star

2018
Jaid Baytos - Attack/Midfield - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Taylor Collins - Midfield - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Abby Collins - Midfield - Liberty League Honorable Mention
Stephanie Scaia - Defense - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
Katie Sergeant - Attack - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

2019
Jaid Baytos - Attack/Midfield - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Abby Collins - Midfield - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Sydney Roderick - Attack - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star

2021
Madelynn Barnum - Midfield - Liberty League 1st Team All-Star
Grace Hagberg - Midfield - Liberty Leagne 2nd Team All-Star
Anna Patterson - Defense - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Sydney Roderick - Attack - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Katie Sergeant - Midfield - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

2022
Madelynn Barnum - Midfield, - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Sydney Roderick - Attack - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Rylee Ganter - Defense - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

2023
Madelynn Barnum - Midfield - IWLCA Empire Region 2nd-Team All-Star
- Liberty League 1st Team All-Star
Rylee Ganter - Defense - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Julia Lavarnway - Attack - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
Lauren Shanahan - Midfield - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

2024
Madelynn Barnum - Midfield - USA Lacrosse All-American Honorable Mention
- IWLCA Empire Region 2nd-Team All-Star
- Liberty League 1st Team All-Star
Rylee Ganter - Defense - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Julia Lavarnway - Attack - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Ireland Morgia - Defense/Midfield - Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

2025
Madelynn Barnum - Midfield - USA Lacrosse All-American Honorable Mention
- IWLCA Empire Region 1st-Team All-Star
- Division III All-ECAC
- Liberty League Offensive Player of the Year
- Liberty League Midfielder of the Year
- Liberty League 1st Team All-Star
Rylee Ganter - Defense - Liberty League 2nd Team All-Star
Gabby Cranfield - Attack - Liberty League 3rd Team All-Star