Brandon BARCOMB - Sr., SS, Cadyville, NY/Seton Catholic
- All-New York State - First Team
- ECAC Upstate All-Star - First Team
- Liberty League All-Star - First Team
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (4/25)

Stefan CASEY - Jr. RHP, Waterbury, VT/Harwood
- Liberty League All-Academic

Rob COWIN - Jr., C, Albany, NY/CBA
- Liberty League All-Star - Second Team

Dan HOJNACKI - Sr. RHP, Attica, NY/Attica
- ECAC Upstate Co-Pitcher of the Week (4/25)
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (4/25)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jay JOSEF - Fr. OF/P/IF, Liverpool, NY/Liverpool
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Year
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (4/11)
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (4/18)

Tom LILIENTHAL - Sr. C, Baldwinsville, NY/Baldwinsville
- Liberty League All-Academic

JJ LORENCE - Sr. RHP/IF, Liverpool, NY/Liverpool
- ESPN the Magazine/COSIDA Academic All-America District I Team
- All-New York State - Second Team
- ECAC Upstate Pitcher of the Year
- ECAC Upstate All-Star - First Team
- Liberty League All-Star (Pitcher) - First Team
- Liberty League All-Star (Outfielder) - Second Team
- ECAC Player of the Week (5/9)
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (5/9)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Andy NOONAN - Sr. RHP, Central Square, NY/Central Square
- All-New York State - Second Team
- Liberty League All-Star - First Team
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (4/18)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Mike ONISK - Sr. OF, Baldwinsville, NY/Baldwinsville
- Liberty League All-Academic

Brian THEILEMANN - So., 3B, Troy, NY/Troy
- Liberty League All-Star - Second Team

Chris TODD - So. C, Glover, VT/Lake Region Union
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jaime TUNISON - So. SS, Ithaca, NY/Ithaca
- Liberty League All-Academic