Mickey BOOTH - Fr., IF, Middletown, NY/Minisink
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (4/24/2006)

Mike BRESETT - Fr., OF/IF, Norwood, NY/Norwood-Norfolk
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (3/13/2006)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (5/1/2006)

Darrell CAREY - Jr., RHP, Bohemia, NY/St. John the Baptist
- New York State Region All-Star First Team
- Liberty League All-Star First Team
- Liberty League All-Tournament Team
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (4/17/2006)
- ECAC Upstate Co-Pitcher of the Week (4/17/2006)
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (5/1/2006)
- ECAC Upstate Pitcher of the Week (5/1/2006)

Stefan CASEY - Sr. OF, Waterbury, VT/Harwood
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League All-Academic

Greg CHOJECKI - Fr. RHP, West Seneca, NY/St. Francis
- Liberty League All-Star Second Team
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (3/13/2006)

Rob COWIN - Sr., C, Albany, NY/CBA
- Liberty League All-Tournament Team

Matt HOLIDAY - Fr., DH, Syracuse, NY/Bishop Ludden
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (3/20/2006)

Matt MELLERT - So. 2B, Penn Argyl, PA/Penn Argyl
- Liberty League All-Academic

Brian THEILEMANN - Jr., 3B, Troy, NY/Troy
- Liberty League All-Tournament Team

Chris TODD - Jr. 3B, Glover, VT/Lake Region Union
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jaime TUNISON - Jr. RHP, Ithaca, NY/Ithaca
- Liberty League All-Academic