Matt Curry - Jr., 2B, Richland, NY/Pulaski
- ABCA/RAWLINGS New York All-Region (2nd Team)
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star (Unanimous)

Jerry Coleman - Fr., C/RHP, Potsdam, NY/Potsdam
- Liberty League Second-Team All Star
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (3/16/09)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (5/11/09)
- Liberty League Championship All-Tournament team

Matt Giordano - Sr., OF, Liverpool, NY/Liverpool
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Co-Player of the Week (4/27/09)
- Liberty League Championship All-Tournament team
- Liberty League All-Academic

Cale Giroux - Sr., OF, Cortland, NY/Gordon
- NCAA DIV. III New York Regional All-Tournament Team

David Goerold - So., RHP, Clifton Park, NY/Shenendehowa
- ESPN The Magazine/CoSIDA Academic All-America District 1, Second Team
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League All-Academic

Matt Holiday - Sr., 1B, Syracuse, NY/Bishop Ludden
- ESPN The Magazine/CoSIDA Academic All-America, District 1, Second Team
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- ECAC Upstate Player of the Week (3/23/09)
- Liberty League Co-Player of the Week (3/23/09)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Brady Torbitt - Jr., OF, Fulton, NY/Mexico
- ABCA/RAWLINGS New York All-Region (3rd Team)
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League Championship Tournament Most Outstanding Player
- Liberty League Championship All-Tournament team
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (5/11/09)

Greg Chojecki - Sr., RHP, West Seneca, NY/St. Francis
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (3/23/09)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Pete Clarke - Fr., SS, Tully, NY/Christian Brothers Academy
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (3/30/09)

David Kinney - Fr., IF/RHP, Mexico, NY/Mexico
- NCAA DIV. III New York Regional All-Tournament Team
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (5/4/09)

Austin Pitkin - Sr., RHP/IF, Dexter, NY/General Brown
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (4/20/09)
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (5/4/09)
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (5/11/09)
- Liberty League Championship All-Tournament team

Chris Falteisek - So., OF, Baldwinsville, NY/CW Baker
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jake Groszewski - So., RHP, Rochester, NY/Bishop Kerney
- Liberty League All-Academic

Justin McInerney - So., RHP, Grand Island, NY/Grand Island
- Liberty League All-Academic