Scott Desmond - Jr., Midfield, Enfield, CT
- ESPN The Magazine/CoSIDA Academic All-America, District 1 - First Team
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League All-Academic

Nate Hazen - So., Midfield, Dalton, MA
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
- LOTTO North Country Classic All-Tournament team (9/6/09)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Mark Secko - Jr., Midfield/Striker, Shoreham, NY
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
- Liberty League Co-Offensive Performer of the Week (9/7/09)
- LOTTO North Country Classic All-Tournament team (9/6/09)

Brian Buckner - So., Striker, Farmington, NY
- Liberty League Co-Offensive Performer of the Week (9/21/09)

Elliott Carter - So., Midfield, Ottawa, ONT
- Liberty League All-Academic

Todd Coleman - So., Back, Vestal, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Matt Konecnik - So., Back, Waterford, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Adam Lamoureux - Fr., Goalkeeper, Falmouth, ME
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (9/7/09)
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (10/26/09)

Brett Laudermilch - Jr., Back, Lebanon, PA
- Liberty League All-Academic

David Maiorino - So., Midfield, Holbrook, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Scott Stuart - Fr., Goalkeeper, Ottawa, ONT
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (9/14/09)

Jeremy Toscano - Jr., Back, Brockport, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Justin White - Jr., Back, Dewitt, NY
- LOTTO North Country Classic All-Tournament team (9/6/09)