Bryan Chudy - So., Pitcher, Goshen, NY
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (5/23/2011)
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (4/11/2011)

Jerry Coleman - Jr., Infielder, Potsdam, NY
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (3/21/2011)
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (3/14/2011)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Chris Falteisek - Sr., Outfielder, Baldwinsville, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

David Goerold - Sr., Pitcher, Clifton Park, NY
- ESPN The Magzaine/CoSIDA National Academic All-America (Second Team)
- ESPN The Magazine/CoSIDA District 1 Academic All-America (First Team)
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League Championships All-Tournament Team
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (5/16/2011)
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (5/9/2011)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Sam Grainger - Sr., Catcher, Bedford, MA
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star

David Kinney - Jr., Infielder/Pitcher, Mexico, NY
- ABCA/Rawlings Third-Team All-America
- National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association NCAA Division III Position Player of the Year Finalist
- NYS/Rawlings First-Team All-Region
- ECAC Upstate Player of the Year
- Liberty League Player of the Year
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Championships Most Outstanding Player
- Liberty League Championships All-Tournament Team
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (5/23/2011)
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (5/16/2011)
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (4/25/2011)
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (4/11/2011)
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (4/4/2011)

Pete Lasecki - So., Infielder, Stratford, CT
- Liberty League All-Academic

Justin McInerney - Sr., Infielder/Pitcher, Grand Island, NY
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Liberty League All-Academic 

Garrett Russell - Sr., Outfielder, Lake George, NY
- Liberty League Championships All-Tournament Team

David Wixted - Fr., Outfielder, Ballston Lake, NY
- Liberty League Championships All-Tournament Team
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (5/16/2011)
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (3/14/2011)