David Kinney - Sr., Infielder/Pitcher, Mexico, NY
- D3Baseball.com All-American Honorable Mention (Utility)
- D3Baseball.com New York All-Region First Team (Utility)
- ABCA/Rawlings New York All-Region Second Team (Utility/Pitcher)
- ECAC Upstate First-Team All-Star (First Baseman)
- Liberty League Player of the Year
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star (unanimous)
- ECAC Upstate Hitter of the Week (4/24/2012)
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (4/23/2012)
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (4/9/2012)
- Liberty League Co-Performer of the Week (3/19/2012)

Bryan Chudy - Jr. Pitcher, Goshen, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Co-Pitcher of the Week (3/26/2012)

John Coleman - Fr., Infielder, Potsdam, NY
- Liberty League Rookie of the Year
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star 
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (4/23/2012)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (3/19/2012)

Jerry Coleman - Sr., Infielder/Pitcher, Potsdam, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League All-Academic

Dan Lenney - So., Outfielder, Clifton Park, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jarrod Mattingly - So., Pitcher/Outfielder, Philadelphia, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

David Wixted - So., Outfielder, Ballston Lake, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League All-Academic