John Coleman - Jr., IF - Potsdam, NY
- Capital One/CoSIDA Academic All-American Third-Team
- Capital One/CoSIDA Academic All-District 3
- ECAC Upstate First-Team All-Star
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star (unanimous)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Greg Jasek - So., RHP/IF - Chittenango, NY
- ECAC Upstate First-Team All-Star
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- Division III ECAC Upstate Pitcher of the Week (5/6/2014)
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (5/5/2014)
- Liberty League Honor Roll (4/7/2014)

Jarrod Mattingly - Sr., RHP/IF - Philadelphia, NY
- Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention
- Capital One/CoSIDA Academic All-District 3
- Liberty League Honor Roll (4/14/2014)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Pete Roma - Sr., RHP, Endicott, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star

David Wixted - Sr., OF - Ballston Lake, NY
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- Capital One/CoSIDA Academic All-District 3
- Liberty League Honor Roll (5/5/2014)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Tim Beninati - Jr., C, Schoharie, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ian Castle - So., RHP, East Greenbush, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Matt Jenack - Jr., C/IF, Massena, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Dan Lenney - Sr., OF, Clifton Park, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jim Kane/Nick Cacciola/Jerry Coleman
- Liberty League Coaching Staff of the Year