Cam Bando - Fr., Designated Hitter/Catcher (Wakefield, MA)
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
- ECAC North Rookie of the Week (3/21/2017)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (3/20/2017)

Joe Fraser - Fr., Infielder (Clifton Park, NY)
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

Chris Miller - Sr., Outfielder (Ballston Lake, NY)
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star

Dom Pirro - Sr., Outfielder/Pitcher (Liverpool, NY)
- d3baseball.com All-Region New York First-Team
- ABCA/Rawlings All-Region New York Second-Team
- ECAC North First-Team All-Star
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Performer of the Week (3/20/2017)
- Liberty League Honor Roll (5/1/2017)
- Liberty League Honor Roll (4/17/2017)
- Liberty League Honor Roll (4/4/2017)

Andrew Smith - Jr., Pitcher (Carthage, NY)
- Liberty League Honor Roll (4/17/2017)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ted Wilson - Sr., Pitcher (Lancaster, NY)
- ABCA/Rawlings All-Region New York Third-Team
- ECAC North Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- ECAC North Pitcher of the Week (4/11/2017)
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (4/10/2017)
- Liberty League Pitcher of the Week (3/27/2017)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Mike Bonk - So., Infielder (Northborough, MA)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Will Coleman - Jr., Pitcher/Infielder (Potsdam, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Rory Corcoran - Jr., Pitcher (Massena, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Nolan Duda - So., Outfielder (Latham, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ben Knauf - Jr., Outfielder (Spencerport, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ethan Kornbrek - So., Pitcher (Somerville, NJ)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Mike Krick - So., Catcher (Cicero, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ryan Riley - So, Pitcher (Sharon, MA)
- Liberty League All-Academic