Kevin Calnan - Sr., Forward (Winchester, MA)
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Offensive Performer of the Week (9/5/2017)

John Furcick - So., Midfield (Poughquag, NY)
- CoSIDA Academic All-District 3
- Liberty League All-Academic

James Homan - Jr., Defense (Clifton Park, NY)
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III Men's Scholar All-East Region Third-Team
- Liberty League All-Academic

Mack Walton - Fr., Midfield (Chester, VT)
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
- ECAC North Rookie of the Week (9/12/2017)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (9/11/2017)

Riley McDonald - Jr., Goalkeeper (Niskayuna, NY)
- Liberty League Honor Roll (10/23/2017)

Chris Afonso - Jr., Midfield (Shrewsbury, MA)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Henry Gomez - So., Forward (Germantown, MD)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ben Jackson - Jr., Midfield (Cold Spring Harbor, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Chris Jupin - So., Defense (Rexford, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Brian Kroetz - Sr., Forward (Pittsford, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Ian Roeloffs - So., Goalkeeper (Warwick, NY)
- Liberty League All-Academic